Mamma Melrose v 50's Prime Time

[JulesAyr]

So I've booked Mamma Melrose for dinner but an now toying with 50's Prime Time. I've read positive and negative for both. We are on DDP so cost isn't a factor really.

Which would you recommend and why?

[THOscar]

Had the worst meal we've ever had at Disney at mamma Melrose in 2015. We go every time to 50s

[Floridatilly]

We enjoyed our meal at mama Melrose last year. We also though about 50's prime but was not keen on the menu 😳

[DisneyWishes]

Not been to Mama Melrose but did 50s Prime Time in October and everyone enjoyed their meals. I have the mums sampler (Fried Chicken, pot roast and meat loaf) and it was delicious. We would definitely go again. 😋

[lovewdw]

Another vote for Mamma Melrose, I much preferred it to 50's

[ChoppyGirl]

Not been to Mama Melrose but we went to the 50's Prime Time Cafe a couple of years ago and loved it. It was one of the only ddp meals we ate all of - it was delicious. I would recommend the PB & J milkshake and they are big enough for you to have a to go cup too

[apple-fan]

Mama Melrose is always on my girls list of restaurants to eat at every year we go, its a lovely atmosphere, decent food...always had great service as well

[scoobydooby]

Have eaten at both multiple times and it's difficult to compare as they are very different. I like both but prefer Mama Melrose. My kids and DH love 50's for the puddings and the milkshakes.