new ships versus old ships

[BarryandCaron]

Originally Posted by BevS97

We've done both. The adult pool was fine on the Dream, it was the family pools that were far too busy. You couldn't swim, just really wade in and stand shoulder to shoulder with other people!

See more...

Originally Posted by Sarah84

This is one thing that worries me about cruising

See more...

Me too but I'm hoping the WBTA pools won't be too crowded on the Magic.

[margyloveswdw]

We've sailed on the Wonder and the Fantasy and are heading off on the Magic in May. I'm worried that on the smaller ship there will be less to do as I thought the Fantasy was fab. Much preferred the adult only areas too.

Agree with the look of the main pool on the Fantasy, always seemed to contain loads of people but that doesn't bother us as we didnt use it.

[Bats]

We've sailed them all and the Fantasy beats the Dream hands down.

The adult only area on the Fantasy is excellent as lessons wrere learnt clearly.

The Magic/Wonder are a different kettle of fish altogether and not really comparable.
The Classics are beautiful, have a much nicer adult pool area and are small so very cosy .. you see the same people sometimes and actually recognise them. On the Dream/Fantasy, I rarely had this as it was so much bigger.

My choice would be:
Magic and Fantasy ... if only one choice, probably Fantasy
Wonder
Dream

[Guest]

Originally Posted by BarryandCaron

Me too but I'm hoping the WBTA pools won't be too crowded on the Magic.

See more...

The adult pool is generally ok... except when there's a handstand competition in progress

Originally Posted by margyloveswdw

We've sailed on the Wonder and the Fantasy and are heading off on the Magic in May. I'm worried that on the smaller ship there will be less to do as I thought the Fantasy was fab. Much preferred the adult only areas too.

Agree with the look of the main pool on the Fantasy, always seemed to contain loads of people but that doesn't bother us as we didnt use it.

See more...

By the look of it, adults are better caterer to than the dream...with that upstairs area. But I've never really found a major problem oncebyounturf off the lounge hoggers

[jdybnsn]

We've done both types and would say both have their pluses and both have their minuses... after sailing the new ships it wouldn't put me off sailing the old ships (and vise versa).

[DIBBadmin]

This thread has been automatically closed as it has not been posted on in 365 days.