Help me decide please!

[Floridatilly]

Trying to finalise my ADR's because I keep changing my mind.
We have worked out that we can save a few TS credits and have one 2 credit meal, we want one that has the tip included and that's great fun for kids as well as adults. (I assume other signature places you still have to pay a tip?)
They don't want to do CRT as my daughter does not like anything on the menu.
So it looks like it's between;
spirit of aloha, I love the look of this but worried about it being cancelled due to weather and don't really know much about the food reviews.
Mickey's back yard BBQ - not sure about the seating though? Benches? I do like to have personal space and not squashed etc
Hoop de doo - don't know much about this at all but husband pointed it out last night, what is the entertainment like, food like etc? The desert looks rubbish too.
My children will be 14, 12 & 4, we are all up for a laugh and enjoy loads of food with a very sweet tooth.
Or would you stick to my original plan if Minnie's seasonal dinner ?

[HelenJNT]

I haven't been to any of them other than Hoop De Doo (there's a review of it in my 2016 TR if you're interested).

The show is great fun. The food is somewhere between mediocre and fairly dismal - I enjoyed the ribs but not much else. But it's all-you-can-drink booze-wise which softened the blow.

[tink18]

We've only done Hoop De Doo and loved it, been three times. Now the food isn't the best, we do enjoy it though. The real value is the show and if you drink the unlimited alcohol included in the cost

[Floridatilly]

lol I don't drink so not much use to me lol

[Jedi_Angie]

We've done Aloha and Hoop-de-doo - and loved both of them. The food was pretty good at both, and although I was skeptical about the desert at HDD, it was suprisingly yummy! I would happily go back to either.