The Irishman

Lisbon · 27 Dec 19, 11:39 AM

Has anybody watched this.
We decided to watch it as our Xmas viewing last night as a family
OMG what a waste of time, two of us decided to stop after two hours but myself and DD decided to stick it out.
It is over three hours long and that's three hours we will never get back.
We felt we had to take notes almost to keep up with the various names and parts of history involved.
It was almost like a " serious " Goodfellas ( how someone gets pulled in to the crime ) but no where near as good.
No real idea why it was called The Irishman as well - because of the war he could speak Italian, so the only referral to him being Irish was at the start when he said he was Irish

Has anyone else watched it and thought differently
Rob

happytraveller · 27 Dec 19, 04:29 PM

I thought this was good if you followed the story, almost like an audio book rather than looking for what we had in good fellas. I was able to enjoy it from that perspective. But whereas with Goodfellas and can watch that over and over again, the Irishman, I don�t feel would get me to do that. I do think it�s good, but not on the level we have seen all those involved before. I also think they should have got younger actors for the flashbacks

**gjdjud** · 28 Dec 19, 02:03 PM

There is a thread hear running about it.

https://www.thedibb.co.uk/forums/sho... php?t=1153621

27 Dec 19, 11:39 AM	#1
	27 Dec 19, 11:39 AM Lisbon Imagineer
Lisbon Imagineer Join Date: Jul 10 theDIBB Guidebook Pages Created: 1	The Irishman Has anybody watched this. We decided to watch it as our Xmas viewing last night as a family OMG what a waste of time, two of us decided to stop after two hours but myself and DD decided to stick it out. It is over three hours long and that's three hours we will never get back. We felt we had to take notes almost to keep up with the various names and parts of history involved. It was almost like a " serious " Goodfellas ( how someone gets pulled in to the crime ) but no where near as good. No real idea why it was called The Irishman as well - because of the war he could speak Italian, so the only referral to him being Irish was at the start when he said he was Irish Has anyone else watched it and thought differently Rob

27 Dec 19, 04:29 PM	#2
	27 Dec 19, 04:29 PM happytraveller Imagineer
happytraveller Imagineer Join Date: Feb 04	I thought this was good if you followed the story, almost like an audio book rather than looking for what we had in good fellas. I was able to enjoy it from that perspective. But whereas with Goodfellas and can watch that over and over again, the Irishman, I don�t feel would get me to do that. I do think it�s good, but not on the level we have seen all those involved before. I also think they should have got younger actors for the flashbacks

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode